Can some TV shows help and others hurt?

By Lauren Mazzo
Photo: PhotoTalk // Getty Images

Tired of stressful news ruining your resolution-crushing endorphin high? Minnesota-based fitness chain Life Time Athletic wants to put a stop to exactly that.

They've officially outlawed cable news on the televisions in all 128 of their gym locations nationwide. The company released a statement on Twitter saying that the decision was made as a result of "significant member feedback received over time" and their "commitment to provide family-oriented environments free of consistently negative or politically charged content."

Life Time isn't the first gym chain to do so: In April 2017, a.k.a. Stress Awareness Month, Blink Fitness (a gym chain in the greater New York City area) announced that they'd ban cable news from their gym TVs every Monday in an effort to keep the gym vibe stress-free. Their initiative, called "Tune Out While You Work Out," was supposed to help members minimize stress and focus on themselves and crushing their workout while they're in the gym.

Should You Ditch the News During Your Workout?

The idea behind the news ban isn't to shut the TVs off, mind you-just to switch to mood-lifting and news-free content in order to totally tune in to the workout at hand. Die-hard news fans might not be too happy about the switch, but turning off the news to minimize stress isn't such a bad idea. According to the American Psychological Association, 76 percent of Democrats and 59 percent of Republicans list "the future of our nation" as a significant source of stress.

"I would venture to guess that if a person watched something they strongly disliked, that would then affect their overall enjoyment during exercise," says Brian Rider, Ph.D., assistant professor of kinesiology at Hope College and the author of a study on the link between TV and exercise enjoyment, published in the Journal of Sports Science and Medicine.

Should You Ditch Workout TV Altogether?

Tuning into news might not be great, but TV, in general, can actually be a good thing. When exercisers watched TV in Rider's study, they reported significantly greater enjoyment compared to those who exercised without watching TV-whether it was a program they chose or a neutral program. In his study, Rider had exercisers walk on a treadmill at an easy to moderate pace while watching 1) nothing, 2) a neutral show about nature, or 3) a sitcom or other show of their choice. They reported enjoying the workout much more whether they tuned into their fave Netflix comedy or just watched color-changing frogs on The Animal Planet.

However, another study published in the Journal of Sports Science and Medicine-which had exercisers watch a 10-minute clip of Two and a Half Men while briskly walking on the treadmill-found that people who didn't enjoy the show didn't get the same mood boost post-exercise as those who did enjoy the show or who had a neutral opinion about it. In fact, for those who aren't fans of Two and a Half Men, they had the same lack of mood change as the control group who didn't exercise at all. (And considering the post-exercise high is basically a happiness drug, you definitely don't want to miss out on that.)

The main takeaway: If the TV is on, you're going to be happier about spending time on the treadmill, as long as it's a show you like or a show you don't mind watching. And if you were planning to watch the latest episode of The Walking Dead anyway, why not do it while being active instead of vegging on the couch? (BTW, you could burn more than 300 calories briskly walking on a treadmill during just one of those episodes, according to Netflix.) But if you can only find shows that aggravate you? Switching it off and turning on an energy-boosting playlist might be your best bet.

It's important to note that both of these studies only tested walking on the treadmill. "Research suggests that as the intensity increases, the less likely a distraction (such as TV or music) is going to impact your enjoyment of exercise," says Rider. Translation: You're getting so in-the-zone from the workout itself, it doesn't matter what's going on around you. Just think about when you zone out during that extra-hard climb during spin class. (Although, we do know that blasting music does increase the likelihood that you'll enjoy a HIIT workout.)

The Best TV Shows to Watch At the Gym

Having trouble picking a show? You can always turn to a health-related reality show like The Biggest Loser or NBC's Strong for some extra motivation. Though there's no concrete evidence (yet) to support it, "I do believe there is a chance that watching a motivating program or one that focuses on sport/fitness could have an effect on a person's enjoyment/motivation/performance during exercise," says Rider. Because if Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives can stimulate a serious appetite, Khloé Kardashian's Revenge Body will only bump up your urge to go hard during your workout, right?

Comments (2)

November 3, 2018
hey i found a rapid weight loss program that can help you lose up to 23 pounds of pure body fat in just 3 weeks!!! watch this video here ->
October 27, 2018
Did you know there’s a “deep detox” you can do first thing in the morning to burn more fat? you can burn 1.2lbs daily and It only takes 13-seconds! watch this video :