You are here

The Absolute Best Mascaras On the Market for Every Lash Look

Find Your Perfect Mascara

1 of 10

All photos

There are few makeup products quite as essential as the humble mascara. Whether it's a "no-makeup makeup" vibe, or a full-on dramatic nighttime look, you better believe we're not going out without it. The only problem? There are thousands upon thousands of formulas out there, at every different price point, promising everything from fuller to longer to more lifted lashes. (#Firstworldproblems, but still.) So to help you sift through them all, we narrowed it down to nine options in various different categories. Keep reading to meet your perfect mascara match.

Photo: Ralf Hiemisch / Getty Images

Best Overall Mascara: Glossier Lash Slick

2 of 10

All photos

There's good reason why we deemed this worthy of a Shape 2018 Beauty Award. It took the brand 248 formulations to come up with the final winner, an effort well worth it. The end result? A lengthening formula that uses baby fibers to coat lashes from root to tip for extra length and definition. It earns a coveted spot as our go-to, everyday mascara time and time again.

buy it: $16

Photo: Glossier

Best Natural Mascara: 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Lengthening Mascara

3 of 10

All photos

Clean beauty queens will appreciate the certified organic ingredients in this mascara, all meant to provide a hefty dose of nourishment and conditioning to your delicate lashes (think oat and wheat proteins). A blend of black tea, berries, and cocoa give it its pigment—surprisingly black for a natural formula—and a subtly fruity scent, too.

buy it: $26

Photo: 100% Pure

Best Waterproof Mascara: Eyeko Sport Waterproof Mascara

4 of 10

All photos

Talk about staying power: We've worn this to a morning spin class and left it on for the rest of the day, with nary a smudge or flake in sight come nighttime. Credit a waterproof gel formula that repels water (and sweat, for that matter), yet still comes off easily with eye makeup remover so that it doesn't wreak havoc on your lashes.

(Related: This Makeup Line Is Sweat-Proof and All Under $8)

buy it: $26

Photo: Eyeko

Best Volumizing Mascara: Bare Minerals Lashtopia Volumizing Mascara

5 of 10

All photos

There are a whopping 600 bristles on this brush, made to hold more mascara and coat each and every lash. The result? Serious volume (up to 10x more volume, to be exact), not to mention all-day flake-resistant wear. The whipped formula also feels—and looks—lightweight, for an extra fluttery fringe.

buy it: $19

Photo: Bare Minerals

(Another) Best Volumizing Mascara: Ardell Mega Volume Never Flat Mascara

6 of 10

All photos

Okay, we're admittedly a little biased—volumizing formulas are our fave. So we have two on this list because we just couldn't pick. Ardell may be known for its amazing falsies, but with this mascara, you don't even need 'em. The thick brush coats every lash, adding both volume and a little bit of curl. We also like how non-smudgy it is.

buy it: $13

Photo: Ardell

Best Curling: Seraphine Botanicals Curl Imperial High-Definition Mascara

7 of 10

All photos

Most makeup artists will tell you that you should be using a lash curler pre-mascara. But when time is of the essence, a curling formula is the next best thing. An hourglass-shaped brush helps separate and lift lashes, while unique copolymers seal in both the jet black color and curl. It's also buildable, and it won't clump even if you like to swipe on multiple coats. 

(Related: This Is Meghan Markle's Go-To Lash Serum)

buy it: $24

Photo: Seraphine Botanicals

Best Colored Mascara: L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Mascara Deep Burgundy

8 of 10

All photos

We get it, colored mascaras can be intimidating. But don't be afraid of them. They're a surprisingly subtle way to enhance your eyes without having to go through all the effort of eyeliner and/or shadow. We especially like this burgundy option. It's the same internationally best-selling thickening formula, but in a rich maroon hue that's especially flattering on light eyes.

(Related: These Bold Fall Makeup Trends Will Make You Look and Feel Like a Boss)

buy it: $8

Photo: L'Oréal

Best Dramatic Mascara: Nars Climax Mascara

9 of 10

All photos

When you want lashes that pop with a capital P, reach for this newbie. The multitasking formula does it all, adding noteworthy volume, lift, and curl. Still, a moisture complex in the creamy formula keeps your lashes feeling soft, never stiff or brittle. 

buy it: $24

Photo: Nars

Best Drugstore: Maybelline New York Total Temptation Mascara

10 of 10

All photos

Maybelline New York has got the drugstore mascara game down (one tube of the brand's iconic Great Lash is sold every 2.5 seconds in the U.S.). But this latest is giving the O.G. a run for its money. With just one coat, the buildable formula makes even the puniest of lashes look lush and dense. A light coconut scent is just a nice bonus. And at under $10, it doesn't get better than that. 

buy it: $10

Photo: Maybelline


Add a comment