Beauty Makeup TikTok Users Say This $5 Mascara Is Better Than More Expensive Brands The formula creates a falsie-like effect in as little as one coat. By Rebecca Deczynski Published on February 25, 2021 Share Tweet Pin Email We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more. Photo: Adobe Stock When you find a good mascara, the impulse to tell everyone you know is hard to resist, especially when it's also an absolute steal. That's why TikTok has been abuzz about one particular lash-lengthening pick. Essence's Lash Princess Mascara (Buy It, $5, amazon.com) is a favorite of users on the video-sharing app — and more than 89,000 Amazon shoppers consider themselves fans, too. The Lash Princess line of mascaras from Essence includes four formulas, but it's the False Lash Effect Mascara that's earned the most praise. In a video that got nearly 3 million views, TikTok user @shelbybmorris demonstrated how the mascara looks compared to her naked, natural eyelashes — and the difference between the two was pretty staggering. Another video by @juliarosemondbeauty showed how the Essence mascara compares to another viral option, Maybelline's Sky High Mascara (Buy It, $9, amazon.com); in terms of volume and length after just one coat, the Essence mascara was the clear winner. Not to mention, it happens to cost $4 less than the competition. All that said, it shouldn't be too surprising that the drugstore buy is currently Amazon's best-selling mascara. A full, cone-shaped brush makes it easy for the volumizing and lengthening formula to coat every lash (even in the corners), and shoppers say it doesn't clump or flake throughout the day. One reviewer who's called this mascara their holy grail for the last three years reported that they always get asked if they're wearing falsies — the results are just that good. ( Gigi Hadid revealed her hack for extra-voluminous lashes — and it includes this $11 mascara Amazon Buy It: Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara, $5, amazon.com "Five years ago I had to undergo chemo treatment and my eyelashes never grew back to their pre-cancer state," wrote one customer. "I have tried all kinds of mascaras (most pretty expensive), and none have stood up to this brand. It doesn't clump, cake, or look like you applied too much. Stays all day." Another shopper added: "I've run the gamut from cheap drugstore brands to high-end department store brands, and none work as well as this. I've had friends ask me if I'm wearing false eyelashes and where I got them because they look so natural. I thought I might have to scrub it off with an oil-based makeup remover, but was happily surprised to wipe it clean with micellar water and a cotton ball." For just $5, many customers have discovered their new go-to mascara. And at a price point that stellar, with a cult-following to boot, this might just become your favorite, too. Was this page helpful? Thanks for your feedback! Tell us why! Other Submit Shop More Shape-Approved Picks The Activewear Brand Jennifer Garner and Jennifer Lopez Wear Has a Hidden Section of Comfy Workout Underwear The 5 Best Amazon Weekend Deals for Up to 75% Off, According to Shape’s Shopping Expert Zumba Lovers Rave About These $80 and $37 Sneakers for Preventing Foot and Joint Pain, but Which Pair Is Best?