Beauty Makeup This $9 Mascara from Amazon Has Even Won Over Self-Proclaimed 'Mascara Snobs' Now’s your chance to snag the recently restocked lengthening formula. By Jayla Andrulonis Jayla Andrulonis Website Jayla Andrulonis is an Austin-based editorial copywriter for Everly Health and a freelance writer who specializes in fashion, beauty, and wellness. Her work has appeared in People, InStyle, Real Simple, HelloGiggles, Health, Parents, and Travel+Leisure.She completed internships at INKED and Whirl publications and the College Fashionista website before becoming the community engagement coordinator for HERdacity and a commerce fellow at Mashable. Jayla has also covered the latest street style trends, wedding planning ideas, and celebrity news for SHEfinds as a contributing writer. She joined Meredith Corporation as an e-commerce editorial assistant and e-commerce writer before landing at Everly Health. Shape's editorial guidelines Published on March 11, 2021 Share Tweet Pin Email We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more. Photo: Amazon As much as making the splurge on things like celebrity-approved leggings can be worth it, sometimes corners are meant to be cut. Especially when it comes to the products you use nearly every day — like mascara, for instance. ( TikTok Users Say This $5 Mascara Is Better Than More Expensive Brands While there are plenty of designer formulas out there, price doesn't always equal better quality. In fact, some of the most popular mascaras out there will cost you even less than a salad from Sweetgreen. According to hundreds of shoppers who've already snagged it, Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara (Buy It, $9, amazon.com) is one such formula you should have on your radar. It's not just the thrifty beauty shoppers of Amazon who've made the switch, though. One review left by a self-proclaimed ″mascara snob″ went on to say how their lashes have never been longer calling it, "worth the hype." Noted. ( Jenna Lyons' Line of Falsies Are the Antidote to Heavy Strip Lashes The secret to how the mascara gives lashes such a va-va-voom effect lies in one simple difference: its brush. The best-seller is designed with a flexible brush that bends and flexes to fully reach each lash for a pristine coat. And since the mascara is infused with bamboo extract and fibers, the result is dramatically lengthened lashes that don't feel heavy. "This mascara is the best I've ever used," one shopper said. "It gives effortlessly long, voluminous, fanned out, feathery lashes with one coat. Two coats makes it even better!" The brush applies so thoroughly, shoppers are likening its effects to being as impressive as false lashes — and calling it a dupe for pricier mascaras on the market. In terms of staying power, reviews for the best-seller say it "lasts all day" without clumping, flaking, or smudging.( Gigi Hadid Revealed Her Hack for Extra-Voluminous Lashes — and It Includes This $11 Mascara "In my opinion it's a dupe for the Thrive Causemetics mascara, and honestly even better," another shopper shared. "This mascara lengthens your lashes so well, it looks like you have on false lashes. Maybelline has some of the best affordable mascaras and this one does not disappoint. The mascara did not flake or smudge on me at all. I put it on in the morning (including bottom lashes) and wore it until 11:00 pm and it still looked great. This will be my new holy grail mascara at such an affordable price." If you're looking to get your hands on the mascara that's already winning over hundreds of shoppers, head to Amazon to snag the recently restocked formula for $9. Ulta Buy It: Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara, $9, amazon.com Was this page helpful? Thanks for your feedback! Tell us why! Other Submit Shop More Shape-Approved Picks The 5 Best Amazon Weekend Deals for Up to 75% Off, According to Shape’s Shopping Expert Zumba Lovers Rave About These $80 and $37 Sneakers for Preventing Foot and Joint Pain, but Which Pair Is Best? Carrie Underwood Called These Sneakers 'the Most Comfortable Shoes' for Her Sensitive Knees